INFORMATION ABOUT PROJECT,
SUPPORTED BY RUSSIAN SCIENCE FOUNDATION

The information is prepared on the basis of data from the information-analytical system RSF, informative part is represented in the author's edition. All rights belong to the authors, the use or reprinting of materials is permitted only with the prior consent of the authors.

 

COMMON PART


Project Number19-12-13051

Project titleSynchrotron self-absorption in active galactic nucelei: astrophysics and applied applications

Project LeadKovalev Yuri

AffiliationP.N.Lebedev Physical Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences,

Implementation period 2019 - 2020 

Research area 02 - PHYSICS AND SPACE SCIENCES, 02-705 - Galaxy and Metagalaxy

Keywordsrelativistic jets, active galactic nuclei, radio astronomy, radio interferometry, VLBI, synchrotron radiation, synchrotron self-absorption, astrometry, reference frames


 

PROJECT CONTENT


Annotation
We will conduct new and continue to use existing radio interferometric observations with very long baselines (VLBI) to study the physical conditions in relativistic jets of active galactic nuclei (AGNs) on parsec scales, exploring the effect of shifting the absolute position of the core with frequency. The shift is due to the properties of synchrotron self-absorption of radiation near the central engine. The aim of the project is to determine the physical conditions in the areas of jets close to the central supermassive black hole for the largest sample of many hundreds of quasars: the magnitude of magnetic field, electron density, geometry of a jet and its energy. We will nearly double the number of sources in a framework of our ongoing research compared to the results of the main Project 2016. Physical modeling of jets and direct comparison with observational data in the spatial frequency domain will be carried out to obtain geometrical and physical parameters of the objects. We will use the measurements of linear optical polarization of active galaxies to verify the interpretation of the effect of the shift of the positions of active galaxies between the radio and the optical bands of the electromagnetic spectrum, which we discovered. The different contributions of thermal and non-thermal radiation from an accretion disk and a jet, respectively, will manifest themselves differently in polarization. In addition to astrophysical applications of a fundamental nature, we will continue to work on improving the accuracy of the applied use of compact extragalactic objects in astrometry and navigation, making it possible to refine the inertial reference system. In addition to the ongoing high relevance of studying the nuclei of galaxies and their jets in general (see the open questions in a review by Blanford et al. ARA&A, arXiv: 1812.06025), we highlight the following for this particular project. 1) Our discovery in 2016 of shifts of the VLBI-Gaia positions and the explanation of the nature of the disk-jet system has initiated a new direction in astrophysics. Now, scientists have a new way of model recovery of information about the centers of active galaxies in visible light on the scale of sub-parsecs. The proposed verification of this interpretation through the polarization properties will become a critical test of the method. 2) The release in 2018 of the ICRF3 catalog (https://www.iers.org/IERS/EN/DataProducts/ICRF/ICRF3/icrf3.html), in fact, ran into the the accuracy limit of the coordinates associated with the effect of the core shift and non-point radio structure. The proposed Project will provide astrometrists with a basis for moving towards further refinement of both ICRF3 and alignment of the high-precision radio and optical inertial reference systems. All proposed studies are new.

Expected results
1. Measurement results of jet directions as well as frequency-dependent shifts in the position of the VLBI core of active galaxies for about 1000 objects according to planned observations at the VLBA in 2019 (our application was approved with the highest priority) using the self-referencing method. Results of measurements of frequency-dependent shifts in the position of the VLBI core of active galaxies for about 100 objects according to our recent observations with the VLBA using the phase-referencing method (see method development in the Project 2016, Voitsik et al., 2018, AF, 95, 822 ). 2. Results of measurements of the core shift in the objects of special interest based on VLBA observational data: radio galaxy M87, gigahertz peaked spectrum quasar 0858-279, as well as quasars 1655 + 077 and 2201 + 315, with rich radio structure of their jets. 3. Assessment of the physical and geometrical parameters of ultra-compact relativistic jets in hundreds of active galactic nuclei previously unexplored for this effect: the magnitude of the magnetic field, electron density, geometry of a jet and its energy. As a result, the number of objects with measured shifts and the results of the evaluation of the physical parameters of the jets will increase by a factor of two compared to what we have done to date. 4. Comparing the properties of linear optical polarization for active galaxies with a significant shift of positions from radio to optics downstream and upstream the direction of the jet will allow us to separate the dominant contribution from the thermal disk radiation and non-thermal jet radiation, checking our interpretation of the causes of the shift. This will not only lead to the verification of our previous results, but will also finally open the way to using the data for the model reconstruction of the sub-parsec structure of the centers of active galaxies — disc-jet systems — in visible light. 5. In addition to astrophysical applications of a fundamental nature, the results of the project will improve the accuracy of direct applied use of compact extragalactic objects (inertial reference frame in the radio band ICRF3 and its alignment with the optical reference frame Gaia DR2 and higher; navigation). Assessment of the compliance of the planned results with the world level of research: The planned results will determine the global level of research of active galaxies in the same way as our early results and the results of the Project 2016 on this topic determine its current level (Kovalev et al. 2008, A&A, 483, 759 - 139 citations; Pushkarev et al. 2012, A&A , 545, A113 - 96 citations, Kovalev et al., 2017, A&A, 598, L1 - 22 citations, and the article submitted to MNRAS a month ago by Plavin et al. arXiv: 1812.06025). We are not only planning to further increase the mass character of the studied sample as compared with our result we obtained earlier. We will also check by a new independent method our astrophysical interpretation of astrometric shifts in the positions of the galactic nuclei between the radio and the optical bands discovered in the Project 2016. The possibility of practical use of the planned results of the project: As part of the extension, we will obtain data on frequency-dependent core shifts in approximately 1000 more compact extragalactic objects. The results have the most important practical application, since they lead to a real increase in the accuracy of the coordinates of these objects on a level better than 0.1 milliarcseconds. Therefore, to: 1. Increasing the accuracy of the inertial reference frame built on compact extragalactic radio sources (ICRF3). 2. Improving the accuracy of the comparison of ICRF3 and high-precision optical reference frame Gaia DR2 and later releases. 3. Improving the accuracy of measurements of the parameters of the Earth's rotation and, accordingly, navigation (the GLONASS system).


 

REPORTS


Annotation of the results obtained in 2020
The scientific group is completing the work on the project, having processed new extensive observational material in the last year of its implementation and received results that will have wide further development. We carried out and processed quasi-simultaneous VLBI observations at 2 and 8 GHz for one thousand VLBI-Gaia quasars, carried out on the VLBA aperture synthesis system as part of our application. Their analysis made it possible to obtain the most massive measurements of the frequency shifts of the nuclei of active galaxies. This huge observational material will allow us to study in more detail the previously discovered nuclear shifts between radio optics (VLBI-Gaia), to estimate the misdirectionality of emissions in radio between sub-pc, pc and kpc scales, as well as its relationship with the geometry of the jet. Measurements and analysis of frequency-dependent shifts in the position of the VLBI core in 142 objects of the MOJAVE-II sample were carried out by the method of two-dimensional cross-correlation of optically thin emission regions using images reconstructed at different frequencies (5, 2, and 1.4 GHz) with the same radiation pattern size , field of view and pixel size. Estimates of the magnetic field strength in the VLBI core and at a distance of 1 pc from the true start of the jet are obtained. Two-frequency maps of the distribution of the spectral index, which characterize the energy distribution of the emitting particles, have been constructed, combining the images over the regions with the optical-thin regime of synchrotron radiation, the positions of which are achromatic. In addition to massive studies of large samples of AGNs, we paid attention to individual interesting objects. The radio galaxy M87 is perhaps the most popular and most thoroughly studied AGN today, and it would seem difficult to discover something previously unknown about this object. Nevertheless, on the basis of unique highly sensitive VLBI data at 8 and 15 GHz, the most detailed map of the spectral index of the radio emission of this object on parsec scales was obtained, which for the first time in detail demonstrates the presence of at least three components in diameter associated with the central channel and the shell. The flattening of the spectrum in these regions indicates a significant stratification of the plasma in the M87 jet. Taking into account the Faraday rotation, which we carried out, allowed us to reconstruct the picture of linear polarization of radiation, which agrees with the structure of the magnetic field expected in the framework of the MHD theory. The analysis of multifrequency multiepoch observations of quasar 0528-279 - a representative of the class of objects with a peak in the radio spectrum at frequencies of the order of 1 GHz. The source is unique in its class due to the rapid variability of the amplitude of this peak, which is uncharacteristic for such objects because of the significant size of the structure components emitting at peak frequencies. The analysis performed allows us to conclude that the reason for the variability is the high value of the Doppler amplification of the radiation of particles accelerated by a shock wave in a relativistic plasma formed upon impact on a dense cloud of the medium surrounding the jet. The reacceleration of particles in this shock wave leads to an unexpectedly high magnetic field strength at a great distance from the central engine. The physical parameters of jets in active galaxies are usually estimated indirectly, based on modeling their structure with a set of Gaussian components. We have previously shown that a physical emission model can be used to estimate parameters directly - by comparison with multifrequency VLBI data. We generalized the previously used model of a relativistic longitudinally inhomogeneous jets to flows with transverse stratification. Observational results obtained in the framework of the grant on the significant stratification of the M87 radio emission turned out to be very useful and were used by us for interpretation within the framework of a generalized model. It turned out that the effect of spectrum flattening associated with the presence of a lower energy limit for emitting particles more adequately describes the central structure with a flat spectrum than the effect of synchrotron self-absorption. At the same time, it became clear that for a complete description of the entire variety of observational information (including linear polarization), further generalization of the model to the case of global magnetic fields is necessary. We have also addressed a few additional interesting problems within the subject of the grant that were not originally planned in the application. Let us mention one of them, the results of which are selected to be included as one of the achievements in the 2020 report of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Determining the sources of astrophysical neutrinos and studying the mechanisms of their formation is extremely important for understanding high-energy processes in the Universe. Using data from the IceCube neutrino telescope, observations on international radio interferometric networks and on the Russian RATAN-600 SAO RAS, it was found that high-energy neutrinos are born in the central regions of bright blazars, that is, active galaxies with jets directed at us. Protons are accelerated along the jets, the neutrinos they produce fly in the same direction. Therefore, neutrinos from blazars are recorded on Earth. The moments of arrival of neutrinos coincide with powerful bursts of synchrotron radiation in compact jets of these objects within the central several parsecs.

 

Publications

1. Alexander Plavin, Yuri Y. Kovalev, Yuri A. Kovalev, Sergey Troitsky Observational Evidence for the Origin of High-energy Neutrinos in Parsec-scale Nuclei of Radio-bright Active Galaxies The Astrophysical Journal, Номер 2, Том 894, 13 страниц (year - 2020) https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab86bd

2. I.N. Pashchenko, A.V. Plavin, A.M. Kutkin, Y.Y. Kovalev A bias in VLBI measurements of the core shift effect in AGN jets Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Выпуск 3, Том 499, страницы 4515–4525 (year - 2020) https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staa3140

3. M. L. Lister, D. C. Homan, Y. Y. Kovalev, S. Mandal, A. B. Pushkarev, A. Siemiginowska TXS 0128+554: A Young Gamma-Ray-emitting Active Galactic Nucleus with Episodic Jet Activity The Astrophysical Journal, Number 2, Volume 899, p.141 (year - 2020) https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aba18d

4. Matthew L. Lister, Dan C. Homan, Yuri Y. Kovalev, Soham Mandal, Alexander B. Pushkarev, Aneta Siemiginowska TXS 0128+554: A young gamma-ray emitting active galactic nucleus with episodic jet activity Astronomische Nachrichten, том 342, выпуск 9-10, стр. 1117-1120 (year - 2021) https://doi.org/10.1002/asna.20210056

5. T. G. Arshakian, A. B. Pushkarev, M. L. Lister, T. Savolainen Studies of stationary features in jets: BL Lacertae I. The dynamics and brightness asymmetry on sub-parsec scales Astronomy & Astrophysics, Том 640, 16 страниц (year - 2020) https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202037968

6. Y.Y. Kovalev, A.B. Pushkarev, E.E. Nokhrina, A.V. Plavin, V.S. Beskin, A.V. Chernoglazov, M.L. Lister, T. Savolainen A transition from parabolic to conical shape as a common effect in nearby AGN jets Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Выпуск 4, Том 495, страницы 3576–3591 (year - 2020) https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staa1121

7. Y.Y. Kovalev, D.I. Zobnina, A.V. Plavin, D. Blinov Optical polarization properties of AGNs with significant VLBI–Gaia offsets Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Выпуск 1, Том 493, 5 страниц (year - 2020) https://doi.org/10.1093/mnrasl/slaa008

8. Косогоров Н.А., Ковалев Ю.Ю., Перучо М., Ковалев Ю.А. Parsec-scale properties of the peculiar gigahertz-peaked spectrum quasar 0858-279 Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, том 510, выпуск 1, стр. 1480-1494 (year - 2022) https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stab3579

9. - Астрофизик Юрий Ковалев об изучении тайнт Вселенной РНФ дайджест, РНФ дайджест #2 (2020) (year - )


Annotation of the results obtained in 2019
Our scientific group successfully continues to study the frequency-dependent effect of the position shift of the radio nucleus in active galaxies. At the same time, we continue to study the nature of the significant shifts between the radio (VLBI) and optical (Gaia) position of active galaxies discovered as a result of our previous work under the grant. In the work, we still use the previously proven approach, which includes combining several methods: considering a large number of objects to obtain robust statistical conclusions; unique observations of individual objects for a detailed study of their properties; development and use of new methods for data analysis and, finally, expansion of observational material. We previously predicted that the shifts between the radio and optical position of active galaxies along the jet direction are due to the dominant contribution of the optical emission of the outflow. If so, then objects with a predominant contribution of jet optical radiation should exhibit a higher degree of integrated optical linear polarization than objects with shifts in the opposite direction. The latter, according to our interpretation, are caused by the contribution of the optical radiation of the accretion disk, which means that they should have a lower degree of optical polarization. Our analysis of a sample of quasars using data in the optical range fully confirmed our predictions. Moreover, as it turned out, the distribution of the direction of polarization relative to the direction of the jet for the shifts has a significant peak at zero deg. That is, optical data allow us to study the jet structure. This, together with the previously discovered relationship between the “radio-optics” shifts and the optical colors of active galaxies, makes such shifts an even more attractive and promising tool for mass analysis of the “disk-jet” system in these objects. From a practical point of view, such shifts must be taken into account to increase the accuracy of comparison of the inertial reference systems constructed in the radio and optical ranges. Our previously proposed method for studying the VLBI structure of collimated outflows by fitting a model of an inhomogeneous jet in the spatial frequency plane, as it turned out, allows not only to estimate the physical conditions in the jet. It was this model that initially made it possible to explain the effect of the core shift observed in radio jets, which is the subject of our interest in the Project. Being a more accurate model than the commonly used sets of Gaussian functions, the proposed method allows to detect subtle details of the structure that were previously inaccessible for detection and analysis. Thus, against the background of a model inhomogeneous jet, we managed to detect a “counter-core” feature in the counter-jet region that was previously unnoticed in the data used for the analysis of the radio galaxy NGC 315. The dependence of its properties on the frequency allows to associate this component with a sharp gradient of the external density near the SMBH (r ~ 0.1 pc), which coincides with the characteristic size of the region of formation of wide emission lines observed in this object in polarized light in the optical range. The “external” nature of the opacity that forms the “counter core”, in turn, allows to obtain an estimate of the velocity of the jet plasma (> 0.7c) in this region. An analysis of the discrepancies between the data and the “inhomogeneous ejection + counter-core” model, as well as the posterior predictive verification of the fitted Bayesian model, indicate that the conical jet form is an adequate description of the outflow geometry for the data used (8.1 - 15.4 GHz). This conclusion is confirmed by the obtained values of the physical parameters of the jet. Thus, the magnetization of the flow turns out to be close to 1, which is predicted by the theory of jets acelerrated in the phase of the parabolic outflow, which have passed to the conical flow stage, characterized by an approximately constant speed. The group not only uses new methods to analyze existing data, but also works on obtaining new extensive observational material. Thus, quasi-simultaneous VLBI observations are being carried out at 2 and 8 GHz of one thousand VLBI-Gaia quasars with VLBA in the framework of our proposal, which has been granted the highest priority. We started data reduction of first observational sessions, as well as the observations of nearly two hundred objects from the MOJAVE-II sample at 1.4, 2, and 5 GHz for further analysis on measuring the frequency-dependent shift of the VLBI core position and determining its direction with respect to the inner jet direction. Of particular note is the analysis of dual-frequency VLBI data from the radio galaxy M87 (Virgo A). And not only because of the object of study, which has become the most recognizable representative of active galaxies due to its relative proximity, but also because of the record dynamic range achieved using our data (~20 000:1). Processing such deep observations is especially complicated and requires numerous checks of the result due to the possible significant influence of instrumental effects. Using simulations, we confirmed the significance of the detected effect of flattening the emission spectrum of relativistic particles in the central channel of the jet. At the same time, our analysis showed that the flattening of the spectrum at the jet edges might be associated with different coverage of the spatial frequency plane (i.e., effective resolution) in the synthesis of images at two different frequencies.

 

Publications

1. A. T. Deller, W. M. Goss, W. F. Brisken, S. Chatterjee, J. M. Cordes, G. H. Janssen, Y. Y. Kovalev, T. J. W. Lazio, L. Petrov, B. W. Stappers Microarcsecond VLBI Pulsar Astrometry with PSRπ II. Parallax Distances for 57 Pulsars The Astrophysical Journal, том 875, номер 2, 28 страниц (year - 2019) https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab11c7

2. A. V. Plavin, Y. Y. Kovalev, and L. Y. Petrov Dissecting the AGN Disk–Jet System with Joint VLBI-Gaia Analysis The Astrophysical Journal, Номер 2, том 871, 8 страниц (year - 2019) https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aaf650

3. Kutkin A.M., Pashchenko I.N., Sokolovsky K.V., Kovalev Y.Y., Aller M.F., Aller H.D. Opacity, variability, and kinematics of AGN jets Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Выпуск 1, Том 486, Страницы 430-439 (year - 2019) https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz885

4. Pashchenko I.N., Plavin A.V. Inferring the jet parameters of active galactic nuclei using Bayesian analysis of VLBI data with a non-uniform jet model Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Выпуск 1, Том 488, страницы 939-953 (year - 2019) https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz1677

5. Plavin A.V., Kovalev Y.Y., Pushkarev A.B., Lobanov A.P. Significant core shift variability in parsec-scale jets of active galactic nuclei Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Выпуск 2, том 485, страницы 1822–1842 (year - 2019) https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz504